seagate laptop thin 500GB SSHD Boxshot

Seagate Laptop Thin ST500LM000 500GB SSHD Review

  • Introduction
  • Seagate has been doing Hybrid drives are some time now, starting with the first Momentus XT drive. Back then, getting an SSD was a pretty expensive investment for a lot of people.

    A lot has changed since then in the SSD market, and it is still evolving but at a very rapid pace. With 256GB SSDs now available at a time for what 90GB/120GB drive used to cost back then with lot better reliability and the price per GB for SSDs has become more realistic. To top it off, we have SSDs with 7mm thickness, targetting those who want better performance for ultrabooks as well. Suffice to say that consumer and more-than-consumer class SSDs are almost halfway across overtaking mechanical drives’ capacity bragging right, and now that controllers and flash NAND are becoming more versatile, lower power consumption and much quicker, added with drives that can easily slide through 26TB of total write, it would be interesting to see how Seagate’s 7mm thick solid-state hybrid drive performs.

    For those who don’t know, Solid-state hybrid drives are those drives that have a flash NAND in an effort to provide bit better loading times for OS and for applications compared to traditional mechanical drives but also use drive spindles to store data like any traditional mechanical drive. Now that this drive is 7mm thick, just like SSDs like Samsung 840 and 840 Pro, this can be used in ultrabooks as well.  Keeping aside a handful of SSD drives/firmware/controller rev, reliability has been pretty much solid, unlike the old days.

    As of now, such drives still provides more storage space than SSDs and therefore giving better overall value.

    Moving on…

  • Specification and Closer Look
  • table

    CDI1

    There are 2 variants of 500GB SSHD drives. One is the 5400RPM 7mm that I am testing, ST500LM000 and the 9.5mm 7200 RPM STAN500100 drive that comes as a kit.

    Just like any mechanical drive: the PCB, the drive and a foam sheet in the middle to absorb vibration from the drive unit.

    IMG_3401

    The drive we got uses Samsung K4T5116301 BCE7 32MB chip for Caching, followed by LSI controller for the platter eASIC controller for the NAND viz. paired with Samsung K9LCGY8S1B-HCK0 8GB MLC Flash NAND.

  • Test Bench and Testing Methodology
  • It gives me great pleasure every time I put up a review. Its always good to appreciate the support that the manufacturers give from time-to-time to review their own products and others on behalf of the readers. Thanks to companies such as Asus, Gigabyte, Kingston, WD and Coolermaster who give me hardware support by updating my test rig no strings attached. Thumbs up to these guys! I would like to thank

    • Gigabyte India for providing Gigabyte 890GPA UD3H Rev 1.0 motherboard
    • Asus India for providing Asus 990FX Sabertooth motherboard
    • Kingston Taiwan for providing hardware support with memory kits and SSD drive.
    • WD India for providing WD 300GB HLFS Velociraptor Hard Drive.
    • Coolermaster India for providing Coolermaster GX450 RS-450-ACAA-D3 Power Supply
    Test Setup for:Seagate Laptop Thin SSHD ST500LM000 500 GB 2.5” 7mm SATA III Storage Drive
    Motherboard+ ProcessorGigabyte 890GPAUD3H Rev 1.0+ AMD 965BE
    MemoryKingston KHX1600C9D3P1K28G HyperX Genesis 8GB 1600MHz DDRIII
    Primary OS driveWD 3000HLFS Velociraptor 300GB/ WD Blue AAJS 320GB/ WD 1TB Velociraptor
    Power SupplyCoolermaster GX450
    ChassisAntec Eleven Hundred

    The Benchmarks that I am using are as follows:
    AS SSD– Read and Write (Pass 3)

    ATTO- Test File Size= 0.5 to 8MB- Read and Write Pass 3

    Aida64- Write and Read Access time File Size 64KB Pass 3

    Anvil Benchmark- Compressible and Incompressible run each with 4, 16 and 32MB File Size

    Boot Load Test- (Windows 7 SP1 clean installation with AMD 12.6 drivers+ AHCI drivers pre-installed with Utorrent, Avira Security Suite, Asus Xonar DX+ 7.12.8.1794 Drivers, Netgear WG111 Wireless LAN USB drive software as start-up items) Pass 1-5 (Pass 1= System start from Power Off)

    CrystalDisk Mark Benchmark- with Pass 3, each with 5 re-runs 1000MB File Size

    HDTune Pro- Write and Read Pass 3

    PCMark 7- HDD test

    PCMark Vantage- HDD Test

    Anvil Benchmark- 4/16/32GB File Size in both 0% and 100% Fill test

  • AS SSD Benchmark
  • Although this drive is used for AS SSDs, the tests in these give a good idea of Sequential, 4K Aligned, 4K Aligned with 64Bit thread test and the Access time of the hard drive using incompressible data.

    as ssd

    asssdread

    asssdwrite

     

    While Seagate is standing between WD Blue 500GB LPVT and Seagate Momentus XT 750GB drive, the write speed, on the other hand, seems to be better than the first Momentus XT 500GB drive and WD Scorpio Blue 640GB BEVT. Note that Seagate Momentus XT ST750X003 is a 7200RPM drive with 8GB SLC NAND, whereas WD Blue LPVT is a 5400RPM and WD Scorpio Blue BEVT is also a 5400RPM drive.

    But also do note that Scorpio Blue is a 9.5mm thick drive. So their direct competition is WD Blue 500GB LPVT. In both tests, LPVT has better access time, but the difference between the 2 in read is pretty small.

  • ATTO Benchmark
  • With a transfer sizes from 0.5KB through 8192KB and the total length of 256MB, ATTO measures transfer speed throughout the drive’s storage capacity for both reads and writes.

    atto

    The drive is pretty much maxed out from 4KB file size.

    attoread

    attowrite

    WD Laptop Thin SSHD 500GB does well against LPVT up to 8KB file size test, as far as the rest of it is a minor difference between the two.

  • AIDA64 Access Benchmark
  • aidaread

    aidaread

    aidawrite

    aidawrite

    Keep aside the obvious difference between a ‘pure’ SSD and a Hybrid drive and WD Blue drive is obvious. But as it shows so far WD Blue 500GBLPVT has an upper hand.

  • Boot Load Test
  • bootload

    On the bright side, Seagate Laptop Thin 500GB SSHD has a much better boot load time. As you can see, there is a pretty steep fall between the pass 2 and pass 3, viz. is a good thing. OS loading is where the Seagate Laptop thin drive shines over WD Blue LPVT.

  • CrystalDisk Mark Benchmark
  • CDM

    CDMRead

    cdmwrite

  • HDTune Pro Benchmark
  • hdtread

    HDTREAD

    HDWrite

    HDTWRITE

  • Futuremark Benchmarks
  • pcm7

    PCM7HDD

    Seagate Laptop Thin SSHD shines in this test, having a decent amount of difference over WD Blue 500GB.

    pcmvhdd2

    PCMVHDD

    Importing is a little bit slot, but other than that, there’s no biggie. Windows media centre test favours Seagate Laptop Thin 500 GB SSHD nicely.

  • Conclusion

Application Loading! OS loading! It is quick in this department, rest of it pretty much like a 5400RPM notebook drive. Its 7mm and I am pretty sure the higher-end notebooks and ultrabooks makers will be using this by default. Rest of you are fine sticking with 500gig WD Blue counterpart minus the flash NAND. But looking at the difference in performance against the 9.5mm 7200RPM 750 Momentus XT, I wouldn’t say it’s a replacement. Its simply a thinner form factor. But if you want all of above 7mm SSD? Take a look at 840/840 Pro depending on your budget and performance requirement.

Desktop users? Either you enjoy the goodness of SSDs like Samsung 840 or 840 Pro or pair a SanDisk SSD Cache with your existing mechanical drive.

In any case, Seagate delivers exactly what they advertised with: better application and OS load in comparison with traditional mechanical drives. But what about the cost of the drive???

India (MRP ex. tax)
U.S.U.K.
 Rs. 6,000/-$81.45£65.16

Both WD and Seagate have 1TB versions with 7mm form factor, and WD said that they would be sending it to me shortly. Let us see how that turns out!

Total
0
Shares
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Beyond News. Beyond Reviews. Beyond Guides & Recommendations.

Join the never ending discussions on never ending topics.
Previous Article
IMG_4249

Coolermaster India 'Encore' Product Showcase 2013

Next Article
Samsung_840_250GB_SSD_Boxshot

Samsung 840 250GB SSD Review

Related Posts
Read More

Cooler Master MasterBox NR200P SFF PC Case Review

The Cooler Master NR200P is a very interesting SSF PC case. It provides for motherboards in mini-ITX/ mini DTX layout, a layout which maintains the vertical length of the mini ITX while providing a longer width. Along with the SFX/ SFX-L spec power supplies, this case is to provide some interesting configuration options. miniITX cases come with some expected compromises. But with advancements in design from processors, chips all the way to layout and form factor specs, it reduces that compromise significantly.  In the end, we will see cases like these.
Read More

SEAGATE IronWolf 110 ZA240NM10001 240GB NAS SSD Review

The Seagate Ironwolf 110 SSD is made for small to SOHO NAS arrays. While NAS bays do provide cages with both 3.5"/ 2.5" drives, there are some really small form factor NAS specifically made for 2.5" SATA drives for mechanical and solid-state. There are also 3.5"/2.5" hybrid NAS that uses SSDs as additional caching for the primary storage array. Naturally, this would make a market for NAS specific SSDs. This is the Seagate Ironwolf variant. The Ironwolf 110SSD comes with a set of its marketed features- AgileArray firmware and DuraWrite are two of these firmware specific implementations. These NAS SSDs do that have a 5-year warranty with an included 2-year data recovery support. Though the provision for this data recovery support varies between countries.